NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing on Medical Counselling Updates

 

 

In a significant legal development, the Supreme Court of India has upheld the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s order to revise the NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing State Merit List and conduct the Medical Counselling process afresh. This decision, delivered on December 17, 2024, comes after growing tensions among NEET PG aspirants, who are now speculating on the potential fallout of the verdict.

 

The dispute centers around the validity of the normalization method used to prepare the State Merit List for the NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing. While the Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled in favor of revising the list, the Supreme Court’s intervention has added a new layer of complexity to an already contentious process.

 

Timeline of Events

 

This case stems from a petition filed by Dr. Abhishek Shukla, a NEET PG aspirant who challenged the fairness of the normalization method applied to determine the State Merit List.

 

The Petition: What Went Wrong?

 

Many aspirants filed a petition in the Madhya Pradesh High Court, alleging discrepancies between the State Merit List and the All India Rank List (AIR). According to the petitioners, the normalization process unfairly placed 300-400 in-service aspirants from Madhya Pradesh at lower ranks in the State Merit List than in the All India Rankings.

 

Core Arguments in the Petition:

 

1. Normalisation Concerns: Petitioners argued that the NBEMS (National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences) normalization method was flawed.
   
   
2. Incentive Marks: The petition highlighted the need for the incentive marks provided to in-service candidates to be adequately reflected in the State Merit List.
   
   
3. Impact on Merit: Lower rankings in the State List undermined merit-based Medical Counselling, potentially affecting careers and placements.

 

The Madhya Pradesh High Court accepted these arguments and directed NBEMS to:

• Add incentive marks to candidates’ normalized scores.
  
  
• Disclose the normalized scores for transparency.
  
  
• Redo the State Merit List before starting the Medical Counselling process.
  
  

However, this ruling caused significant disruptions and prompted NBEMS to seek relief from the NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing.

 

Also Read KEA Karnataka Counselling 2024 NEET PG Round 2 Choice Filling Extension

Supreme Court Intervention: Key Highlights

NBEMS approached the Supreme Court, raising concerns over the feasibility of revising the merit list just days before the commencement of Medical Counselling on December 20. NBEMS argued that:

• Conducting counselling with revised scores would lead to operational chaos.
  
  
• The State Counselling Process is already time-sensitive and must be completed on time.
  
  

In response, the Supreme Court issued a stay on the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s order. It also:

• Issued notices to the petitioners and NBEMS.
  
  
• Scheduled the matter for a detailed hearing on January 21, 2025.
  
  

The NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing & decision temporarily halts any changes to the merit list, but aspirants are divided on its implications.

Impact of the Stay Order on NEET PG Counselling

 

The stay order has broader implications for the NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing Counselling process:

 

 

Proposed Solutions to Avoid Future Disruptions

 

To prevent similar issues in the future, stakeholders suggest:

 

1. Transparent Normalisation Process: NBEMS must clearly explain and standardize the normalization formula.
   
   
2. Timely Grievance Redressal: Establish a dedicated platform for aspirants to raise concerns pre-counselling.
   
   
3. Concurrent Merit Lists: Ensure State Merit Lists align with All India Rankings to avoid discrepancies.

 

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

 

Q1: Why did the Madhya Pradesh High Court order the revision of the State Merit List?

The Madhya Pradesh High Court found discrepancies between the State Merit List and the All India Rankings, particularly for in-service candidates, leading to the order for revision.

 

Q2: What is the normalization process in NEET PG? 

Normalization is a statistical method used to adjust scores to account for differences in exam difficulty across sessions.

 

Q3: What does the Supreme Court’s stay mean for the counselling process?

The stay means that the Counselling process will proceed as per the current merit list until further hearings.

 

Q4: When will the Supreme Court decide the matter? 

The Supreme Court has scheduled the next hearing for January 21, 2025.

 

Q5: Will counselling be delayed again? 

If the Supreme Court upholds the High Court’s order, further delays may occur. However, the current stay ensures that counselling can begin on December 20, 2024.

 

The Supreme Court’s stay on the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s order has provided temporary relief but left aspirants in limbo. While the legal proceedings continue, stakeholders and aspirants remain hopeful for a practical and fair resolution that upholds merit and ensures smooth counselling for NEET PG 2024 Supreme Court Hearing.

The fate of the Madhya Pradesh NEET PG counselling process hangs in the balance. The next hearing is scheduled for January 21, 2025. Until then, aspirants must understand the uncertainty while preparing for the next steps in their medical careers.

Also Read DMER Tamil Nadu NEET PG 2024 Round 2 Counselling Seat Allotment Results